The claim: The cougar cannot roar because its hyoid is fully ossified, unlike the flexible hyoid of lions and tigers.
What the evidence says: The correlation holds — roaring cats have an unossified epihyoid and purring cats do not — but the causal explanation does not survive scrutiny. Comparative measurement finds the relevant bones do not differ in shape between purring and roaring cats, and the epihyoid sits away from the vocal apparatus, so its ossification is likely a shared trait of the genus Panthera rather than a functional cause. The snow leopard has an unossified epihyoid and neither roars nor purrs, which is hard to reconcile with the standard story.
Why it persists: It is a tidy mechanical explanation of an obvious difference, and it was in the textbooks long before anyone measured the bones across species.
Where you'll meet it: Field guides and zoo signage · Popular accounts of big-cat anatomy
Sources (2)
- Peer reviewedDeutsch, Ashley R., Langerhans, R. Brian, Flores, Deanna, Hartstone-Rose, Adam (2023)The roar of Rancho La Brea? Comparative anatomy of modern and fossil felid hyoid bonesJournal of Morphology, vol. 284p. e21627Open source
- Peer reviewedWeissengruber, Gerald E., Forstenpointner, Gerhard, Peters, Gustav, Kübber-Heiss, Anna, Fitch, W. Tecumseh (2002)Hyoid apparatus and pharynx in the lion, jaguar, tiger, cheetah and domestic catJournal of Anatomy, vol. 201pp. 195-209Open source